Was a night in Pensacola
The moon was hanging high
You said you'd reach right up
And pulled it out of the sky
I'm glad it came back

You said you had our future
Planned out like a map
We find a little piece of heaven
No matter where we're at
It's gone just like that

Indian giver, you give and you take
Indian giver, took your love away
And handed it to her
You Indian giver

Might only take a moment
But you'll take your precious time
To steal her innocence
The way you stole mine
The way you stole mine

Indian giver, you give and you take
Indian giver, took your love away
And handed it to her
You Indian giver

Bet you got 'em lined up like a train
And you could sell the sun even when it rains
You needn't take that away
Indian giver, you give and you take

Indian giver, you give and you take
Indian giver, you took your love away
And handed it to her
Yeah, you handed it to her
You Indian giver
Indian giver